Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Felipe Vigne Germini's avatar

The scenario framework is useful, but it underweights a fifth path already unfolding — call it "Managed Leakage." Iran declared the strait closed, but Chinese- and Iranian-flagged tankers are still moving. Bessent confirmed the US is allowing Iranian tankers through. The strait is not closed in the binary sense these scenarios assume. It is selectively closed — which creates a tiered access structure that benefits state-backed fleets at the expense of commercial operators carrying Western insurance. That gray zone between open and closed is where the market actually lives right now, and it may persist far longer than any of these four scenarios suggest.

No posts

Ready for more?